Greenpoint, located in the northernmost neighborhood of Brooklyn, New York, is known for its cozy charm, historic architecture, and great food. Over the years, Greenpoint has evolved into a lively place for dining, with a wide variety of restaurants offering diverse cuisines. From authentic Polish dishes to modern American fare, the neighborhood has something to offer everyone. In this guide, we will explore the best restaurant in Greenpoint: Paulie Gee’s, a beloved spot known for its amazing pizza.
Paulie Gee’s: A Pizza Lover’s Dream
Paulie Gee’s is considered the best restaurant in Greenpoint by many locals and visitors alike. It has earned its reputation for offering some of the most delicious wood-fired pizzas in all of Brooklyn. If you are a fan of pizza, this is the place for you. Paulie Gee’s is located on Greenpoint Avenue, right in the heart of the neighborhood, and offers a warm, rustic atmosphere that’s perfect for enjoying a meal with friends or family.
The Atmosphere and Experience
Paulie Gee’s has a welcoming, cozy vibe that makes every guest feel at home. The interior features a lot of wood, brick, and dim lighting, giving it a rustic and comfortable feel—like stepping into an old cabin that smells amazing because of the pizzas cooking in the big wood-fired oven.
The seating is mainly communal, with long wooden tables that encourage a sense of togetherness. The friendly servers add to the experience, making sure that everyone feels taken care of while dining. The restaurant is a great choice whether you’re visiting with a big group or going for a casual date night.
Paulie Gee’s is not just about the food, but also about the experience. The owner, Paulie himself, often makes appearances, greeting customers and ensuring that everyone is enjoying their time. This personal touch adds a unique charm to the restaurant that makes it stand out from others.
The Pizza: The Star of the Show
The main reason why people keep coming back to Paulie Gee’s is the pizza. The restaurant offers a variety of pizzas that are cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven, which gives them a smoky flavor and a crispy yet chewy crust. Here are some of the standout pizzas that you absolutely must try:
1. Hellboy
- Ingredients: Fresh mozzarella, Italian tomatoes, spicy soppressata, Parmigiano-Reggiano, and Mike’s Hot Honey.
- Why It’s Special: The Hellboy is one of the most popular choices at Paulie Gee’s. It combines the perfect mix of spicy and sweet, thanks to the addition of Mike’s Hot Honey, which is drizzled over the top. The heat from the soppressata pairs wonderfully with the sweetness of the honey, creating a unique flavor that keeps customers coming back.
2. Greenpointer
- Ingredients: Fresh mozzarella, baby arugula, olive oil, and lemon juice.
- Why It’s Special: The Greenpointer is a lighter option that’s perfect for those who want something fresh. The peppery arugula and lemon juice give the pizza a bright and zesty flavor that complements the creamy mozzarella. It’s simple but incredibly satisfying.
3. Ricotta Be Kiddin’ Me
- Ingredients: Fresh mozzarella, Canadian bacon, sweet Italian fennel sausage, and dollops of ricotta cheese.
- Why It’s Special: This pizza is perfect for cheese lovers. The addition of creamy ricotta makes every bite rich and indulgent, while the sausage and bacon add a savory element that balances out the cheese perfectly.
4. Regina
- Ingredients: Italian tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, Parmigiano-Reggiano, olive oil, and fresh basil.
- Why It’s Special: Sometimes, the classics are the best. The Regina is a traditional Margherita-style pizza, with fresh tomatoes, basil, and cheese. It’s simple, but the high-quality ingredients and wood-fired cooking make it taste amazing.
Vegan and Gluten-Free Options
Paulie Gee’s also caters to those with dietary restrictions. There are several vegan pizzas available, which feature vegan cheese made from nuts and lots of fresh veggies. The Vegan Greenpointer is a favorite, with arugula, olive oil, and a delicious vegan mozzarella. The restaurant even offers gluten-free crusts, so everyone can enjoy the experience.
Other Menu Highlights
While the main focus at Paulie Gee’s is the pizza, there are a few other items worth mentioning. For example, their small plates are perfect for sharing and starting your meal. Some favorites include:
- Honey-Drizzled Fresh Ricotta with Bread: A creamy and slightly sweet appetizer that pairs perfectly with their fresh-baked bread.
- Wood-Fired Roasted Veggies: Seasonal vegetables roasted in the wood-fired oven until they’re perfectly tender and smoky.
The drink menu at Paulie Gee’s is also well-curated, featuring a selection of craft beers, wines, and unique sodas. Many of the beers are local, giving you a taste of Brooklyn’s great craft beer scene.
Tips for Visiting Paulie Gee’s
- No Reservations: Paulie Gee’s operates on a first-come, first-served basis, which means there can be a wait during peak hours. It’s best to arrive early to avoid long lines, especially on weekends.
- Takeout and Delivery: If you’d rather enjoy your pizza at home, Paulie Gee’s offers a takeout option. They also have a separate location called Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop, which offers classic New York-style pizza slices.
- Great for Groups: The communal seating makes it ideal for larger groups. Bring your friends and share different pizzas to get a taste of everything.
The Slice Shop: Paulie Gee’s Alternative
If you prefer a more casual, grab-and-go experience, Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop is located just a few blocks away from the original restaurant. The Slice Shop offers New York-style pizza by the slice, which is perfect for those who want a quick and affordable taste of Paulie Gee’s magic. The slices are large, with a crispy crust and plenty of toppings—just what you’d expect from a classic New York pizzeria.
Why Paulie Gee’s is the Best in Greenpoint
There are many great restaurants in Greenpoint, but Paulie Gee’s stands out for several reasons:
- Unique Pizzas: The creative pizza toppings and flavor combinations make it more than just your average pizzeria.
- Wood-Fired Perfection: The use of a wood-fired oven adds a special touch to every pizza, with a slightly smoky flavor and the perfect crust texture.
- Cozy, Inviting Atmosphere: The rustic interior and communal seating create a welcoming environment for everyone.
- Dietary Options: The vegan and gluten-free options mean that Paulie Gee’s is accessible to almost anyone.
Conclusion
Paulie Gee’s is more than just a pizzeria—it’s a place where you can relax, enjoy great food, and be a part of Greenpoint’s wonderful community. The warm atmosphere, friendly service, and, of course, incredible wood-fired pizzas make it the best restaurant in Greenpoint.
Whether you’re in the mood for a spicy slice of Hellboy, a fresh and zesty Greenpointer, or a comforting Ricotta Be Kiddin’ Me, Paulie Gee’s has something to satisfy every craving. So, if you’re ever in Greenpoint, make sure to stop by Paulie Gee’s and experience what many consider the best pizza in Brooklyn. You won’t regret it!